| Hall of Fame - Year | Region | Name | School |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1985 | Central | Jay Dakelman | Highland Park H.S. |
| 1985 | North 1 | Herm Shaw (Posthumously) | Roselle Park H.S. |
| 1985 | North 1 | Skeets Irvine (Posthumously) | Collingswood H.S. |
| 1985 | South | Tom Kenney | Camden Catholic H.S. |
| 1985 | North 2 | Gary Kehler | Westfield H.S. |
| 1985 | North 1 | Joe Coviello | Memorial H.S. |
| 1986 | South | John Boyd | Atlantic City H.S. |
| 1986 | North 1 | Tom Della Torre | Hackensack H.S. |
| 1986 | North 2 | Clary Anderson | Montclair H.S. |
| 1986 | Central | Al Malekoff | Somerville H.S. |
| 1987 | North 1 | Joe Talamo | Pascack Valley H.S. |
| 1987 | North 2 | Joe Kasberger (Posthumously) | St. Benedicts H.S. |
| 1987 | South | George Masters (Posthumously) | Moorestown H.S. |
| 1987 | North 1 | John DePuyt (Posthumously) | Ramsey H.S. |
| 1987 | South | Joe (Rocky) Cancellier | Riverside H.S. |
| 1987 | Central | Ken Keuffel | Lawrenceville H.S. |
| 1987 | Central | Stan (Tex) Rosen (Posthumously) | Perth Amboy H.S. |
| 1987 | North 2 | Abe Smith | Plainfield H.S. |
| 1988 | North 1 | Joe Grecco | Clifton H.S. |
| 1988 | South | Jim Devonshire (Posthumously) | Penns Grove H.S. |
| 1988 | Central | Stan (Tuffy) Baker (posthumous) | Keyport H.S. |
| 1988 | Central | Barry Rizzo | Matawan H.S. |
| 1988 | North 2 | Bill Horey | Glen Ridge H.S. |
| 1988 | North 1 | Red Quirk (Posthumously) | Dumont H.S. |
| 1988 | South | Bill Gordon | Rancocas Valley H.S. |
| 1989 | North 2 | Vincent Carlesimo | Our Lady Of The Valley H.S. |
| 1989 | North 1 | Charles Benson (Posthumously) | Pompton Lakes H.S. |
| 1989 | North 1 | Matty Certosimo | River Dell H.S. |
| 1989 | South | Sam Venuto | Salem H.S. |
| 1989 | South | Joseph Boyd (Posthumously) | Central Regional H.S. |
| 1989 | Central | Joe Gutowski | J.P. Stevens H.S. |
| 1989 | Central | Arnie Truex (Posthumously) | Middletown H.S. |
| 1989 | North 2 | Bill Cochrane (Posthumously) | St. Peter's Prep |
| 1990 | North 1 | Ed Fisco | Dumont H.S. |
| 1990 | Central | Joe Jingoli | Princeton H.S. |
| 1990 | South | Dick Ridinger | Paulsboro H.S. |
| 1990 | South | Joe Pappiano (Posthumously) | Camden H.S. |
| 1990 | North 2 | John Bauer | Randolph H.S. |
| 1990 | Central | William (Butch) Bruno (posthumas) | Asbury Park H.S. |
| 1991 | North 1 | Ken Sinofsky | Wayne Valley H.S. |
Showing 1 to 40 of 287 entries